Originally posted by GlassJunkie Well Said...
If Pentax were slick (I mean REALLY SLICK) the APS-C function would adjust the crop to maximize the available real estate AND possibly moderate the vignette mathematically in the corners, similar to what we do in post-production. Hence, rather than the arbitrary "18mp crop" (or whatever), the profile of each EXIF identifiable lens would generate a crop "sized" for the focal length and crop effects of that lens, at that setting, dynamically... Maxing out the effective MP. 18mp is not enough to mitigate (make us excited about the "auto" APS-C crop feature for BIF shooters).. Cool but complicated programming, but a potential competition killer. The other guys aren't even close to it, since they hype and Push FF as the only "Pro" solution. Pure photographic testosterone and hype.... Get the crop to 30+MP of 42, and I'll buy 2. but 18 is second class for Wildlife/BIF shooters. K-3 unleashed many of us.... Let's not step backward. If the crop is 18mp, I'll wait for the K-? that is 30+ mp (an APSC with 4/3 x 16mp pixel density)...
- Lifting vignetting shadows in camera will reduce DR at the edges and corners. Vignetting sometimes gives a nice intended touch to the image. Vignetting compensation should be overridable, but why spend time on location on setting this details in a menu?
- Choosing crop factor is about weighting corner performance against needs. In portraits people would accept lower corner performance then in landscapes. Who would want to spend time on location considering that in addition to everything else?
- Cropping gives us freedom to choose aspect ratio within the acceptable performance of the image circle. Why spend time on location considering this too?
I don't understand why anyone* would use the auto-crop function. Its better to choose aspect ratio, crop factor and vignetting compensation in the post process. It gives you more time to focus on important things like lights, angles, composition lines, look for the right moment, choosing DoF and so on. This is things you cant compensate or choose in the post process.
* Ok, if i lend the camera to my mother or others that have to be told where the shutter button is, then i probably will set the camera in full auto with auto crop and jpeg just for the convenience.