Originally posted by TwoUptons I like the shots I’ve seen from the Lydith, but there’s nothing about it that strikes me as visually unique from a lens perspective.
And it’s the same price as the 31mm limited where I live, so, yeah, probably not...
-Eric
The Lydith is not a bad lens and has a lot of character. The original lens can be had for €50 or less in this part of the world and comes in either M42 or EXA mount, in Pentacon and Meyer branding. Sure, these old lenses may not be mechanically perfect, often have wear and tear, and misaligned elements are also reported. But at that price you could buy a few and still have plenty of money left...
The story's a bit different for the Trioplans and Primoplans, especially the 75mm version, which are much pricier and harder to come by. If I was in the market for a Primoplan 75/1.9 for €1000 used in ok-ish condition and the brand new Meyer version, I would certainly choose the latter. Or maybe just get the Pentax FA77...
But if my work depended on these lenses and would make enough income from it to pay for them, I would probably pick a new one that I can rely on. Then I don't have to fiddle with flimsy M42 adapters, uneven focus, oily aperture blades and all the other issues these old lenses are plagued by. If you're in that position, it's good to have the option of getting a new copy of the lens.
As far as I know OPC has retained the same manufacturing process and different small repair shops produce the components and assemble the lenses. It appears to be a mostly small-scale operation with a lot of manual work in a high wage country. My hunch is that the profits per lens aren't that small, but they need to be because otherwise the whole business wouldn't be profitable.