Originally posted by creampuff Why would APS-H (1.3 crop) be suicide?
If Canon can have 1.3x crop sensors in their EOS-1D Mark II N and EOS-1D Mark III cameras, and if Pentax lenses can cover an image circle corresponding to APS-H, why would it be a flop?
So far I haven't seen any cogent explanation why it would be detrimental for Pentax to adopt APS-H.
Creampuff,
The answer is simple but unfortunatelly has nothing to do with photography. In short "it's not cool to have a less than FF sensor", "Pentax cannot be taken seriously this way" and so on. I will put here my answer to that from the parallel thread on dpr:
"I really don't care what sensor size my camera has as long as it is: not very big, not very expensive, with the best DR and noise characteristics I can buy for that amount of money. IMO a larger sensor than APS-C with a lower pixel density could be the best compromise in those features vs. the price. Also this could mean a larger VF and the only actual difference in shooting is the new crop factor for the lenses. That's all it matters to me and I really don't live by numbers, acronyms of technology and self esteem validation points. CCD or CMOS, APS-C or other format ... bring it on!
I find it ironic that we tend to criticize 4/3 format for lack of DR and poorer noise control than our APS-C cameras based on sensor size but all of the sudden a 45% increase in area from APS-C to APS-H is not enough and we NEED to go all the way to FF. Also many here celebrate Leica for their totally new 45x30mm sensor format but hey, Pentax must obey the rules and go only FF and follow the rest.
For the final time if this will happen this camera will be more likely priced next to 50D and D300 and not 5D II or D700 so it's the prodigy of the class not the retarded cousin of FF and if this happens ironically they could attract a lot of people that need what FF can deliver in noise, DR and a thinner dof than APS-C but don't need the very high pixel count or to pay the full price of a FF camera.
You are right about the last part I confess I want to believe this as much as probably you don't simply because I'd like Pentax to put in my price range the best tool for the money (according to my criteria's obviously)."
Regards,
Radu