Originally posted by Prognathous If by "old-fashioned focus aid" you mean the split-image or microprism in old focusing screens, then no, it not the same. These aids were in the center of the frame, where as the focus points are spread over a much larger area.
Using the closest focusing point may save some time (in recomposing) compared to using the center point, but the main reason to use it is to avoid the focus-recompose out-of-focus issue described in the links I posted.
Prog.
If you use the *middle* one and pick your range, it *is* the same, more or less. Like I say, a screen for fast lenses without the artificial DOF to brighten up kit lenses in the shop, though, would be most welcome.
(I mean, if you're worried about DOF control with fast lenses wide open, it's not fancier computerized AF you need, to guess where in the frame Joe Amateur wants his focus interpolated: you need glass to focus on. )