Originally posted by jpzk Scott,
First, your photos are stunning.
So, please stop posting them here because I am becoming rather jealous!
Seriously: I see that you have "stacked" two TC's for some of your pics. Granted, you have some fast glass and I would assume this "stacking" would only be possible with fast lenses, right? ... but I wonder if that there is a remote possibility to achieve similar (if not quite as good as those you have) results with slower lenses, i.e.: F4 such as the DA*300.
I am soon getting this Tamron 70-200 f2.8 and I already have a Tamron 1.5x TC. Do you think stacking another TC (such as your 1.7X) on top of it would work with?
Cheers.
JP
Hi Jacques,
Thank you!
I've had success in getting an AF lock with the K-7, FA*300/4.5 + Sigma EX 1.4x APO AF TC, and the 1.7x AFA, but not with the K20, K10, K100DS, or DS.
The difference is the added AF sensitivity of the K-7 AF system. The DA* is 1/3 stop faster than the FA*, so it would probably work with a K-7, and maybe with a Kx. f9.52 (f4 x 1.4 x 1.7) is really pushing it though, and for me, at least, it would only be a last resort type of thing, with cropping possibly being the better alternative. The AF was slow to lock, but it was pretty accurate. If I want/need the longer reach than 510mm, then I'll drag along one of the 300/2.8s. I'd think that stacking 2 1.4x TCs would give better results at 600/8. Some might say that a 2x TC would outperform 2 stacked 1.4xs, but I've yet to use an AF 2x TC that gives better results than the stacked 1.4xs, -- YMMV, of course.
Scott
I forgot to comment about the 70-200. I think that you might be able to stack converters with this lens, but it's always dicey predicting how well it might work. The resultant 476mm f6.7 will probably AF fine, but I've found that pushing the reach of zooms is a possible problem (possibly because of optical design compromises that might have been made to give good zoom performance). I have an SP 80-200/2.8 Adaptall 2 that is and outstanding lens, but though it's great with the AFA, it's not given me results that I like with stacked converters. It's worth a try though. . .
Last edited by snostorm; 01-02-2010 at 05:02 PM.
Reason: added some text