Originally posted by Emacs Well, I'm quite expirienced with 15Ltd and know its weaknesses. It's the lens aimed to produce cartoonish pics and that's all.
Today I'm sure it's the lens of their price $500 and nothing more. Sometimes it's capable of produce stunning results. But sometimes you need too much PP to get something appealing.
Of course, I'm not a pro and uses 15Ltd only occasionally, but pros who were using this lens are tend to agree with me.
For example, shooting portrait indoors using dispersed sunlight from the window. All FA Ltds, FA*, A*, zeisses I tried gives picture with soft lightness transition. In such a conditions (which I found to be perfect) 15Ltd manages to get contrast image.
F%ck, I don't need contrast image here, I don't see such a harsh gradient here, and I don't expect to see it on the photo. But this Ltd does it.
I can tell the same about other DA Ltds (although the effect isn't pronounced as strong as on 15), but this makes those ltds being inferior performers which just don't worth their price.
I was amazed how (relatively) popular DA Ltds on this forum. In our Moscow pentaxian club the majority supposes these DA Ltds are not real Ltds. At least they are inferior compared to FA Ltds.
I guess the insane contrast of DA Ltds is the cost for being sharp enough and small at the same time.
This really is an odd way to look at it. 'high contrast' simply means accurate and very efficient color and light transmition. Unless you're actually talking about some odd color shift, 'high contrast' indicates a better optical design. The microcontrast and tonal transitions and gradients are also more accurate, cleaner, with these high contrast lenses. And if high contrast isn't what you're after, it's easier to drain contrast from an image in PP than it is to add it (skillfully.)
The FA LImiteds have speed and very pleasing rendering, especially and OOF transition with the 77, but it's very hard to make the case that they're really superior to the DA Limiteds, optically. I'm speaking as someone who's favorite lens is probably the 77ltd.
The DA 15 and 35ltd are just remarkable. I really see how great they are after shooting with just 'good' lenses for a week - going back to the 15 & 35 just brings a "
oh, that's here all the color is!" reaction.
.