Originally posted by altopiet This is a very enlightening discussion about something totally beyond my comprehension, but I still try to follow here and there, waiting for an answer to a question I've had for a while about all discussed in this thread, and that is....Do anybody have any idea whether anything discussed have any influence in peoples decision to buy a digital camera, and DSLR specifically, and if it does, what percentage of sales are we talking about, more or less?
It would maybe help to answer this question:
Why would you buy an aps-c DSLR (or mirrorless camera) over a superzoom bridge camera with a new, very-efficient BSI sensor that offers a 28-300 f/2.8 "equivalent" fixed lens?
That "28-300 f/2.8" is pretty powerful, no? It would allow the same exposure over the same FOV as a 28-300 lens on FF, and that sensor is brand new and very efficient. If you didn't like primes, didn't care about VF and AF speed and were just concerned with IQ, why would you ever consider a larger sensor DSLR or MILC? Wouldn't it be a waste of money?
Now here's the thing - any answer you give that involves IQ, even if you're not not using the term equivalence, has the concept baked in. As does the 'low light' score in DXOmark. The Total Light is crucial to the reason why.
What this means is that you can just say, "because the aps-c DSLR has a larger sensor, and it's going to have the capability to give me better images than that P&S". Equivalence/Total LIght is implicit in that answer, just like horsepower is (often) going to be baked into "Car A is faster than Car B."
Now, where the background knowledge of why may help you is if some neighbor or salesman says "why bother with a DSLR, this brand new P&S with this 28-300 2/8 lens is just as good, gets you the same exposure, etc." Might be good to have some facts and methodologies at your disposal to be able to call BS. It also would help you if the sensor sizes are much closer than P&S and aps-c - like aps-c & FF, or especially FF and medium format , because depending on the lens + body combo you're considering
the larger sensor combo may not be better.
Of course it's completely up to you. IMO, it's unseemly to go through life with half-understandings when the truth is so readily available.
And if you're hangin' in a forum like this... It's kinda going to get talked about.
.