Forum Member Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: SF Bay Area (CA) |
Hi,
Currently have the K3, A7, and XT1 after spending two months using the XT1. I will end up with two out of the three because they are so different.
The XT-1 is a phenomenal camera. The design is perhaps the most impressive of any camera in existence today. It is a true photographers tool and every detail was clearly thought out. Most interesting, the XT1 is top of the heep when it comes to being able to balance ISO, Aperture, and shutter speed in a way that results in an image that naturally replicates what your eyes saw in real life. As much as I love the XT-1, it has a few serious flaws (depending on what your priorities are). It is not good for active subjects, the shutter blackout time is long, and most importantly, it has really poor DR on the shadow side. Darks block up very easily relative to other cameras. if your images are of mostly bright subjects its less of a problem. For me, where the darker regions are important, this is a problem. BTW, I don't buy into the whole Fuji jpeg film simulation fanaticism. If I want to be creative, I can do that in post. Its really just a play with contrast and saturation. To be clear, the XT1 has phenomenal image quality, expect for darker areas. DPReview's DR tests confirm my un-scientific visual conclusion. Fuji also cheats with respect ISO ratings, but despite this high ISO performance is quite good. Lens selection is excellent, but some of the older ones are terrible functionally even if the image quality is very good.
The A7 appears to have amazing image quality (I'm still new to it). Its DR, especially in in the shadow area which is important to me, is superior to the XT1. The controls are not as impressive as the XT1, but they are passable. The EVF is actually better than the XT1 imagewise, but not layout or datawise. It is more compact than the XT1 when comparing with Fuji 23mm and the Sony 35mm lenses attached. The A7 is a more responsive shooting experience with a shorter evf blackout time. The biggest flaw of the A7, is the horrible horrible shutter sound.... it is loud as a truck.. Considering that part of moving to mirrorless is to have lighter and more discrete gear, this is a bizarre omission. To be clear, the shutter is much much louder than either the XT1 and the K3. High ISO performance is extremely impressive. Lens selection is far from impressive, but if they have the ones you need it won't matter.
Regarding both the XT1 and A7: As good as the evfs are, they are not great for bright outdoor lighting as they are just too limited in dynamic range.
The K3 is a machine. It is refined, and has perhaps the best functional implementation of any modern dslr. It is fast, responsive, and a pleasure to use outside and for active subjects. Focus accuracy and metering can't match either mirrorless, but this is an issue with all slrs. Its big and heavy relative to the other two, so its not something you are going to take everywhere. Interesting, despite having a mirror box, it is quieter than the other two. While there are lots of pentax lenses, most are the old and noisy screwdriver driven type, which is disappointing. Also, for me, the 35mm FF equivalent focal length is the most important, especially for indoor work. However, Pentax does not have a fast prime to meet this need. Another thing to consider is you are empowered by being able to see the image, as it is to be recorded, when taking the shot and after the fact (in the evf). This is a powerful tool which slrs, including the k3, lack.
Reading this, you might think I am down on the k3. I am not. There is a reality about improvements in mirrorless that make slrs seem like relics. However, there are some things that mirrorless can't do yet. Thus my dilemma is that no one camera meets all my needs. I do not want to compromise on image quality. Therefore, after selling my pentax gear and k5, I have decided that I will supplement a mirrorless with the K3. I haven't decided which mirrorless will stay. Truth be told, at a certain point in the near future, I won't need an slr. Its my hope that Pentax is watching Fuji, Sony, and Olympus, and will respond in kind and with force. I love Pentax and have been shooting Pentax for years, but I won't need a traditional slr for ever.
Last edited by loganross; 05-11-2014 at 09:48 AM.
|