Originally posted by ccc_ he said doctors practice the art of medicine...I thought medicine was a science
Medicine is both science and art!
Science provides tools - methods and tests and machinery to diagnose a problem, treatments and medicines and surgical techniques to try and fix the problem, and an understanding of the cellular and systemic machinery that keeps the human body in operational status.
The "art" comes into play when the doc is looking at the patient and trying to figure out which methods to use in diagnosis based on the input from the patient, physical examination, past experience, and any of the tests described up top. Past experience not only with the doc's overall practice and all of the patients she's seen, but also the particular experience and history with *that* patient. The symptoms in one person can mean something quite different from the same symptom in another person. Sometimes the doc has to use a lot of tests to isolate what is wrong. Sometimes the doc, especially more experienced ones, will have a hunch or a gut feeling that leads them quickly to the problem. Is a subconscious pattern recognition 'science', or is 'an art'? I say it's an art - not everyone can do it, and often the doc doesn't really know why they get a diagnosis like that. They'll use a test or tool to confirm it, but the hunch itself? Art, IMHO...
Jim (ignoring any and all remarks about doctors and Mercedes and money motives applying to all of 'em as a class...)