Originally posted by kenyee Hate to say it, but that photo has craploads of noise
I'd hope the K-3 can do better than that...
And for some odd reason, no one in my family cares, because family gathering pictures for the most part, people look at once, and never look at again. There is one from this series that people may print, that has a much more even exposure and no boosted shadows. So, yes, it has craploads of noise, and yes, no one gives a crap. Except apparently you. That gives me cause for concern. In my world, if the quality of the pictures meets the criteria for which it was taken, then it's met it's objectives. Comments like this suggest that every picture need to meet some outside objective defined by people like yourself. I call it the "trademan's attitude".
I once , when I was working as a cabinet maker, had another tradesman who was visiting me tell me my coffee table needed refinishing. Now when I went to his house, I found his furniture was all way over done and and for the most part, too big for the rooms he had them in. But of course I said nothing. And in the real world, I knew from experience there were people who would go for that look, which to me was overcrowded.
So your comment ,to me is the competitive tradesman kind of thing. And there are a lot of guys who make a living criticizing others work, and then producing a product that for one reason or another can be defined as "better". And in most cases, those reasons are spurious at best.
As in the case of this picture. Not because the criticism is technically wrong, it isn't, but because the criticism is ignorant of the context. I'm not saying you're wrong, you're just being you. I'm saying most people won't give a crap.
The important things about this photo are.
1. No one was interrupted from the conversations etc. that make holiday times important.
2. No one was blinded by an elaborate flash set up.
3. There was no equipment scattered around the room that people had to be careful of.
4. Nothing was done to interfere with the relaxed atmosphere of the gathering.
Check out the list. DO you see anything about low noise photos on that list? For your future reference, it's called a candid shot. The rules used for determining good technical photographs, often don't apply.