I lean toward #1, because I think the simple icon has potential if you want to use it as a watermark. The font has some promise, but it's a little blah, and you might want to use a variation of the font for your name versus the second line, and also adjust the tracking on the second line to make it a bit tighter.
If you want to experiment with fonts, you can have some fun with Adobe Typekit. You can see a snippet of text in various fonts from the main page (by typing text into the box on the main page) and then once you want to take a closer look at a font and its variations, you can click on that font and then use the type tester.
Then take a screen shot of the font and show it to your friend to see if s/he can find something similar and accessible. (I have access to the Typekit Fonts through my InDesign subscription, but there are restrictions on access to use of some of the fonts if you won't have Typekit. But everyone can view and play with them.)
https://typekit.com/fonts