Originally posted by normhead Oh, is this going to be a debate? I thought the question was who is your favourite photographer? Not what's wrong with someone else's choices. .
Now, don't try to say everyone else but you is inflammatory, Norm, we know you all too well ... you didn't just answer the OP's question, you threw in: "But could anyone today do what he did?".
Originally posted by normhead They might be good... they aren't Karsh. And they don't really have the ability to compete from him.
Look, I flew the nationalist flag myself earlier, but fact is, even back in Karsh's day there were plenty of other great celebrity photographers like Philippe Halsman, Arnold Newman, Richard Avedon and Irving Penn. Good luck arguing which one would be the Number One draft pick.
And then there are *today's* photographers.
Low key Shaq, by Gregory Heisler:
Super thin DoF by Martin Schoeller:
Intimate by Mario Testino:
B&W by Mark Seliger:
Let alone all the high-tech strobes, digital sensors, modern lenses and post-processing that David La Chappelle brings to bear: