Originally posted by TER-OR So it might actually be easier to get a good DOF with a longer macro, if you can get more magnification at the same distance? It seems a little counter-intuitive to me. I could use more stand-off distance in some points, and in others would enjoy less heavy cropping. This might be worth investigating.
Thanks for the feedback, guys.
If you're all the way at 1:1 (putting aside extension tubes to get you even more magnification), you of course MUST back up -- the minimum focusing distance will be farther with the 180mm. Basically, if you are using a shorter macro and you think "I wish I could be farther away and get the same shot", then the longer lens will help with that. Or if you shooting at less than 1:1 (and your lens is capable of getting there) but you can't get closer just because it is too damn close, it will also help. If you are already shooting at 1:1 and everything is great, then it won't really get you anything -- it just means you'll have to back up. (At the macro level, anyway. It of course be easier to shoot birds, etc with it as it can be used as a normal telephoto also, and will even work well with a teleconverter.)