Originally posted by LaRee There are some outstanding images in this contest. But I agree with Leo, if they were NOT taken in August then they should be disqualified. Anyone can dig around on their hard drive for their best night shot. I don't think that is the intent of THIS particular contest.
What do you think Adam?
If you have a challenge - then limit the images to the period of the challange. If it is a contest (like here) then let it cover all of your images. I have a few Night images that I could have used - but they were all taken over a year ago. I can get images when I am have down time or I am on vacation, but not during "normal" periods, due to the timing constraints of my job etc.
So if there was to be a contest theme - say Summer - then which hemisphere would be able to participate? Only those in the Northern one - since December is Summer in Austrailia, New Zealnd, Fiji, Chile, South Africa etc. No - I disagree - the images are of the themes - not of the month. My entry for last months contest was taken in 2005, my alternative was taken in 2006.
Would you limit Ansel Adams to not use Moonrise over Hernandez - just because he did not take it in June? I think not.
I do wish however, that people would read and follow the instructions on size, boarders and text on these images. That said, Adam has way too much to do to keep all of us children in line.
If this "contest" becomes like the 90 window challanges on other sites - then I quit. Here and now.
The Elitist - formerly known as PDL