Originally posted by sviro @ Ryan & VTerlaky:
Hey you two. I think it's pretty unfair to submit the profile picture as well. The contest was meant for the banner and everyone else was doing his best with the banner. Now you two step in and submit profile picture as well and thus create an unfair advantage over other submissions. Shame on you two.
I would partially (explained below why) agree with you if Adam hadn't said this publicly in this very thread:
Originally posted by Adam You're welcome to do that, but remember that your primary focus should be the banner!
Since he had said it, it is therefore an equal opportunity game, and if you didn't see his post then shame on you, not us. Remember, Ryan first asked politely (and publicly in this thread) if a profile pic could be submitted along with the banner. I don't know about him, but I only submitted mine (in fact only started working on it) after Adam gave the affirmative answer. I am sure that we are not the only two that submitted a profile pic either...
As for why I would only partially agree with the statement even if Adam hadn't said it was ok to submit a profile pic: even if we had submitted a profile picture without asking first, I think Adam and the site admins would have enough integrity to ignore the unsolicited extra submission, or even disqualify our submissions altogether.
In any case, if you really think it gives such a huge advantage (judging by Adam's response quoted above it looks like it doesn't), then you still have ample time to make one yourself.