I have both and I love them both. The 77 Limited is obviously going to be a favorite because of its size and build, not too mention that most on this forum have only been able to use the 77.
However, as nice as the 77 is, and as ugly and large as the 85* is, I have to go with the 85*. There is absolute magic in that lens. There is a reason why you can buy the 77 Limited used fairly easily while the 85* remains relatively rare despite EBay.
EDIT - Unfortunately, that relative rarity is what will work against it in a popularity contest like this one.