Originally posted by laTimo i will get a samyang 14 for landscape eventually, + 43 ltd and maybe the 50 macro. thats what i initially thought about. But i was/is stilluncertain about the value and quality of my first lens, the 28 105.. Will i regret it, so to speak. But i think not. I want to have a WR lens, since im a sportsfisher and lives near the coast aswell, so because of my active lifestyle a nice WR lens is a must for me. But to start with, how will the 28 105 lens do with landscape/architecture and general walkaround? At portraits my guess is that it will do just fine. Not spectacular, but ok enough.
Based on what you said regarding WR, the
D FA 28-105 is THE option for you. (At least to start.) After a while when you want more lenses you'll know more of what you need. If you shoot a lot in low light, you might end up with the 24-70 f/2.8, but that's not WR. Even if you do buy better lenses in the future, you'll probably want to hang onto the D FA 28-105 for it's ruggedness and WR to use as a foul weather all around lens so you don't ruin any of your fancier gear.
I shoot APS-C, but it's the same story for me. I started with a DA 18-135 f/3.5-5.6 WR which filled most of my needs quite well. For low light and faster aperture I now have a Tamron 17-50 f/2.8, DA 50-200 WR, and a few primes. The 17-50 stays on my camera the most and I use the 50-200 when I need more reach, but if I am going anywhere damp or dirty (rain, beach, camping, etc) I stick with the 18-135 since it can stand up to the elements. Even on vacations I'd rather have one good all around lens than have to switch lenses back and forth and carry extra gear all the time. Even just this morning on my way into work I put the 18-135 on so I could take some shots in a foggy mist without worrying about moisture. The 18-135 would still be my first choice if I could only have one lens ever.
WR is one of Pentax's greatest advantages, so to not have a WR lens would be almost sacrilegious!
*Another small note, the D FA 28-105 will have almost silent focusing while screw driven lenses make more noise. If you do much shooting in quiet places where noise would be a distraction you would be better off using manual focus or a lens with built in DC, SDM, or HSM focusing. (Because of this I also use my 18-135 for quiet ceremonies such as weddings, school shows, etc. where I don't want dirty looks when I auto focus.
)