Let’s get some disclaimers out of the way.
- I’m a hobbyist. Not a professional. Take everything I say with the dead sea’s worth of salt. It’s very likely I’m wrong or something I say is an issue can easily be corrected.
- This is my first pentax camera. I won’t touch on many of the gripes people have about moved buttons because the whole layout is new to me.
- Most of these notes are ill thought out, semi-stream of consciousness impressions. They’ll be rambling, incoherent and contradictory.
- I’m comparing the K-1 to the Nikon D40x. It’s not a fair comparison but since this is the transition I’m making, these are my thoughts.
- I didn’t get to play with the K-1 until after 10pm last night so this is strictly handling impressions only.
It’s big. It dwarfs my D40x. It’s heavy. I’ve obsessed over the numbers but until you get it in your had it’s hard to fully appreciate the weight. I spent most of the night with the FA 43 ltd on the K-1. The grip is deep. I have small hands and the grip is too deep for my personal preferences. YMMV. I don’t like how my ring and pinky fingers jut out more because the grip tapers out a little. On my D40x my pinky would rest under the hand grip (the grip and camera body are tiny) and support it. I always felt the D40x grip was too small but the K-1 goes too far the other way (for my hand size). It’s likely something I’ll get used to and will be a non issue but right now...I don’t want to say it’s a bothersome but it’s conspicuous.
The other thing I noticed is that in part because of the larger grip it’s hard to do thing with my right hand without also supporting the camera with my left.
Despite all this griping about the grip it’s easier to hold than my D40x. Specifically it’s easier to hold while my arm hangs down at my side. This is in part because the thumb grip has a nice rubber and more pronounced protrusion.. Even though the K-1 is double the weight of my D40x, the K-1 feels more secure. The D40x’s thumb grip was relatively shallow and didn’t have any rubber. It was slick and not confidence inspiring. I rarely walked around with it in my hand. It was either out for a shot or slung over my shoulder with a strap.
In my excitement I quickly attached the Sigma 85mm lens…and promptly marked my K-1 (d’oh!). C’est la vie. Combined, they’re an anvil. Seriously, total weight is not to be underestimated. I can now full appreciate why people wouldn’t want to carry that around. I’m keeping the sigma but on dog walks where a lot of one handed pictures will be taken, I’m going with the FA43.
The shutter button: This is one thing I genuinely don’t like about the K-1. The D40x (and all Nikons I’ve used) have a very distinct tactile click at the half press and full press actuation points. Even after 8 years of use, my D40x’s shutter button still feels crisp. The K-1 feels mushy. The best way I can describe the feel is like comparing one of those rollup water proof keyboards to a cherry MX blue mechanical keyboard. It's hard to feel were the half actuation point is. Already I’ve accidentally taken multiple pictures trying to only get it the half way actuation point. Without the audio beep for focus lock, I wouldn't know. And I want to turn off that beep. Given this will be the most used button I wish it had more tactile feedback.
On that note I wish the power on/off ring protruded vertically more. It's pretty stiff.
The function dial and setting dial are also really stiff. I’m sure it’ll break in with time but at present it’s not a one handed operation.
I find that when I try to adjust a AF point I keep hitting the D-pad first and bringing up one of those functions instead of moving the AF point. Something to get used to.
The AE-L is WAAAY easier to use on the K-1 than the D40x. The AE-L/AF-L on the D40x is a tiny button right next to the screen and near the eye piece. It was hard to press without hitting the molding around the screen. It usually required contorting your hand to press while also pressing the shutter button.
I really like the articulating screen. I wish it had just a little more movement to the sides and facing down. But as is, it’s great.
I've looked at that top info screen once. The D40x doesn't have one. I'm not sure if it's because I'm just not used to looking for it or what, but I found myself looking at main screen for the camera info. The top info screen just seems small and cramped.
I know that sounds like a lot of complaining but I am genuinely giddy to get out and use it.
EDIT: This doesn't come across well in text but most of my "complaints" basically boil down to, "I'm just not used this or that and with time I'll have completely forgotten about it". My only real complaint is the shutter button feel.
Last edited by serothis; 06-01-2016 at 09:09 AM.