Originally posted by Robert N
My own limited trials with a 35mm lens at f2.8 required a good black sky for the Type 3 to function. Perhaps the MossyRocks example of a long lens enlarged the stars sufficiently to allow the Type 3 system to pick them up more easily. However, this does not detract from the excellent innovation and ease of use of the Type 3 system.
I have tried it with lenses as short as 28mm and type 3 works fine even in my very badly light polluted backyard which is a bortle 8 location for light pollution with a 9 about a mile away. If you want to find out how bad your location is
you can check it here. I even tried shooting with the full moon just out of the frame and it was able to find enough stars to calculate tracking. From what I have experienced, type 3 will fail to track if the stars get too big like what happens when you are out and the lens gets fogged, or your focus is off. My guess is that unless you manually focused with a bahtinov mask or really fiddled around in magnified live view looking to turn on the dim stars that will flicker if focus isn't perfect your problem was that the focus was off by a bit. With astrotracer it works better for longer lenses as they have a narrower field of view so the movement throught the frame is more similar. Once one gets much shorter than 28mm the corners start suffering as the difference in movement from the center of the frame to the corners is just too different and you get streaking. That isn't to say you can't use it to extend your exposure time beyond the good rule of 200 (200/focal length) but I haven't done that. I should try that out and see if I can get a good 40s exposure with my 12mm as that would double the exposure time.