Morning,
Ballheads - for such a simple concept - holding the camera steady, I find that they generate a great deal of personal opinion. I had an old plastic / aluminum tripod and head ($7) that I learned a lot with. I picked up a Benro travel angle tripod and it came with a ball head. The tripod was great (and I use it a lot). The Benro ball head was a POS. Now having said that, Benro went away and re-designed a series of ballheads, and the B1 was the result and it appears to be very good. I also acquired an old Manfrotto 3001 tripod (with a 486RC2 ballhead). I love the tripod - hate and despise the ballhead.
The Manfrotto 496 series and 054 ballheads are two completely separate designs and concepts. One - the 496, you screw in the camera, while the 054 uses a quick release plate system. The quick release plate system (my opinion) is superior and works much better, especially in terms of work flow. I had a Manfrotto 486 ballhead and I absolutely hated it for several reasons:
- Just a single lever (no friction control) - but both the 496 and 054 appear to solve this problem.
- The quick release plate required 3 hands to operate - 1 hand to hold the camera so as to not flop off (hitting the ground), 2 hands to try to operate the quick release mechanism (one hand to disengage the locking pin, and then needing a second hand to operate the release lever, removing tension on the camera plate, thus freeing up the camera). Maybe it was just me but it was very difficult to operate.
- The Manfrotto quick release plate system - the RC2 in my case, I found it difficult to mount the camera plate in to the clamp. I had already had an Arca-Swiss QR system, and thus I was probably already spoiled on it.
I would just suggest, what ever you buy, to take a look at the following:
- On the ballhead - to tighten, you need a friction control, plus the main control to lock down the ballheads position. A large lever or Knob works better in terms of operation (you get better leverage).
- A quick release system (camera plate and clamp) that is easy to operate with one hand - 1 to hold the camera, and one to operate the clamp release mechanism.
- A reasonably substantial ballhead - not too small, and depending on your application maybe not too large. I found the Manfrotto ballhead itself (forgetting about the plate/clamp and release) to be a wonderful size and built very well. That I liked about them.
- Some type of tightening system that will easily lock down with out slippage. Also, something that will let you make some fine adjustments easily.
The quick release system to me is the key. I like the Acra-Swiss type system, but that will most likely put you out of your price range. I might suggest that since you have other tripods, you probably have a quick release plate/clamp system on those. A common plate/clamp system across all of your "support" equipment would make interchanging them pretty easy. Just a thought.
What it boils down to is that if its easy to use, you will use it, if its difficult its a waste.
After using Benro's "ball head" once, I went and researched ballheads. For me, I went with an Arcatech GP, mainly for the panning and gimbal capability (which I use a lot) along with the A-S quick release system (its easy), but that is out of your price range.
just my 2 cents....
Last edited by interested_observer; 06-25-2012 at 04:59 AM.