Originally posted by Na Horuk Great test! Heh, seems like the 3x TC gives you a "soft focus" lens
I just tried my 35mm with a couple coins and gave up and swapped over to using paper currency. The depth of field gets reduced to thinner than the difference between the coin's surface and whatever is stamped on it. The result is soft because you quite literally have what seems like a tenth of a millimeter that's actually sharp. I was using an old 10 Pence coin and I was watching the focal plane shift back and from the lion's face to the text on the coin. It was insane.
---------- Post added 04-16-15 at 03:27 PM ----------
OK, these aren't perfect (and I forgot to save a full size copy pre-crop of the non-TC shot, so the exposure is off (I did an auto-everythingf or it after the fact). It should give a rough idea of whats going on.
I think the enlarged image IS better for a few reason - first, there were no sharpening algorithms applied as the image was enlarged. Its a straight "WYSIWYG" out of camera shot. I could probably sharpen it up just as nicely as the other shot if I put any effort at all into working over the raw file for it. Second, the depth of field for the enlarged shot is much, much larger. Its not so noticeable with shots of paper like this, but if there was any dimension at all to the subject (coins, bugs, rocks, whatever) then you'd see fuzziness hit almost immediately simply because most of the subject would be sitting outside the focal plane. If I could figure a way to actually stop down the lens attached to the TC, I think we'd see a dramatic difference in quality.
The end result is the enlarged image IS better, but only because its has post work done to it simply through the act of enlarging it.
Original, uncropped shot from the 75-260 (I used this lens because its my best macro lens as far as being able to get close. Its not my best lens IQ-wise, but its the one that allows me to get closest to whatever I'm shooting.) Both shots were taken using a 5500k LED desk lamp for lighting, and tripod mounted with the mirror locked for the shots (really, I put way more effort into this than I should have... LOL). Focus was made in live view to get it as decent as possible. It was while trying this with the coins that I realized coin shots weren't going to work due to the too-small focus plane. Focus was on the 'Z' in Zimbabwe on the hundred trillion dollar bill.
Uncropped:
Cropped and enlarged (No TC):
3X TC shot:
---------- Post added 04-16-15 at 03:30 PM ----------
I'm sitting here wondering how hard it would be to Frankenstein an aperture onto the TC now.
Yeesh.