Originally posted by beachgardener How would you think the peak design every day messenger either 13 or 15 stack up against the hadley or the fstop? I am still leaning toward the fstop.
water proofing?
I don't think the Hadley is wide enough to accommodate a DSLR comfortably. So I think you can eliminate that bag. As far as the Billingham 1.4 and the Peak Design are concerned, it's sort of like comparing a Rolls Royce (Billingham) to a Lamborghini (Peak Design). Both are great bags, just pick the style that you like. With that said however there are a few noticeable differences between the Billingham 1.4 and the Peak Design 13. (I think the 15 is too large IMHO). The Peak Design is more of a triangular shape from the side view and when filled tends to fall over whereas the 1.4 is rectangular and remains more upright when packed. At least this is what I've read and seen on the reviews on both YouTube and Bhphotovideo. The Peak Design has a few more do dad pockets than the 1.4 and also has a zipper located at the top of the bag so you can grab your gear without opening the flap. I think this has its good and bad though. It's a tight fit pulling your gear through the zipper whereas on the 1.4 you can just open the flap and tuck it on the onside and easily grab whatever you need. I also prefer both the style and material of the 1.4 over the Peak Design. The 1.4 is simplicity at its finest while the Peak Design has a more modern feel and look to it.
Waterproofing? The Billingham sheds water easily and keeps your equipment dry. I don't have any experience with the Peak Design.
There have been some complaints about the Peak Design strap sliding around all over the place. I can tell you that the Billingham stays secure. I also use a Billingham shoulder pad as well that fits very comfortably although you have to purchase it separately unfortunately.
I also looked at the Peak Design before I purchased the Billingham 1.4 and again I just prefer the look of the Billingham.
Here's some bag dimensions I pulled off the bhphotovideo website.
Peak Design 13. 17.1 X 12 X 4.3
Billingham 1.4. 13.78 X 9.89 X 6.69