Staff note: This post may contain affiliate links, which means Pentax Forums may earn a small commission if a visitor clicks through and makes a purchase. If you would like to support the forum directly, you may also make a donation here.
Originally posted by beachgardener some of the hoyas might rate well, for me it is B+W or higher end Marumi, why do you want a skylight filter?
I don't lol, that was classic eBay and Bruce fails (I search for 27mm UV filter and eBay gives me that... and then I post it lol).
Yeh the video I linked earlier talked about how sky ones were for film, interesting stuff.
I managed to actually pick up a Marumi 27mm UV filter in a camera store today for $20 so will try that, I don't think its special coated or anything so I might do some testing with that, in fact will test with the Hoya's as well.
Well as you can tell I know very little about any of this, but I have been round the block a few times and I have known of other industries (audio for example) that have products that are 3-4x price of other similar priced products that have in reality very little difference. Placebo exists for real, and sometimes people just want to feel that extra level of comfort feeling that they have the best because they
paid for the best.
Often in audio there's a diminishing return. Yes the $600 pair of IEMs are better than the $60, but 10x better? More like 10%! It really depends, case by case etc.
That reviewer seemed to put a few UV filters through the test, and in the end deemed the Hoya's superior to the B+W. Was he biased? Does this apply only to the 72 or 77mm thread Hoya vs B+W? I really don't know. I'm not made of money so where possible I look for ways out of spending what would have been $180 for 2x B+W and instead paid $50 for the two Hoyas... which are apparently as good if not better, and if they aren't actually better, I doubt they are terrible, and blind testing people to shots and asking them to guess which filter was used would prolly be quite entertaining (a little like ABX testing)
If a lens filter costs similar to a replacement cap then with negligible reduction in image quality, yet offers protection and possible some quicker shooting styles, then I think that's fair. But paying $90 for a filter is quite a lot more than a cap, and I think that's prolly my bail out decision for getting one.
We'll see tho, it could be that the $90 ease of clean B+W pays itself back tenfold compared to these Hoya if they are a PIA to get clean!