Originally posted by gatorguy Well that's interesting. After watching the video and having a go these are the conclusions I'm coming to;
I don't have that pouch, but i wear a pouch belt, I actually use chalk belts as they are soft. If i discard the twisty type rear caps (such as the double optech ones) and instead use a standard 'push only' rear lens cap then there's not a lot of issue with lens swapping without a strap of any kind. You first pop off the rear lens cap off the one you want to put on the camera body, I can do this one handed. Take the current lens off the camera body, put it down into a spare lens pouch, put new lens on the camera and the spare rear cap on the lens you just took off. Nice and easy.
Worth mentioning;
1) if you have sturdy hoods leave them on, then when you place them down into the pouch the lens hood first stops the front element from making contact, and it's a step you don't need to bother with at all (placing the front lens cap back on that is)
2) if you know your shooting frantically for a few minutes you can just discard all the rear lens caps off the lenses in the pouches, put them on after the session, this increases the swapping time a lot!
3) the problem with my currently lens pouches is that the internal fabric is soft but 'loose' this means that the rear element (or even perhaps front element with a shallow hood on) could make direct contact with the inner fabric lining and therefore grab some dust. I think a sturdy lens pouch with fixed lining makes much better sense in this regard, and if the hood is perhaps zipped (but left unzipped) and kinda naturally falls back over the lens when in the pouch and not in use will provide extra protection for the lens sitting inside with no rear cap on.
So i really think this is the direction I will head down. Non rubber hoods, sturdy deep hoods where possible, sturdy pouches that have fixed lining and a cover that naturally springs over once the unprotected lens is placed inside. This would be a wickedly fast lens swapping combo. Take current lens off, dump in pouch face down, grab new lens, place on camera. No lens caps to fuss over, not even rear caps!
Thanks very much for showing me this.
Originally posted by savoche
3rd one looks awkward, too tight with a strap passing the VF. Urgh
2nd one looks too weak and prone to a mishap I agree.
1st one I tried and couldn't manage it at all! Perhaps my strap is different (i'm not using stock ones)... seems like a lot to think about anyway when moving between wrist to neck.