Originally posted by UncleVanya I think it would be easy to over expand the product line. If you start with larger filters to fit many lenses then your first attachment would be a step up ring then a lens adapter like you showed on the 28mm. Imagine a collection of 62 or 72mm filters and hoods and caps all used on every lens under that size. I think that would be the practical approach. Perhaps two sets, one larger for the larger lenses. This would likely require a lot of adapters. But it looks very easy to use.
Yeah. In the past I have bought a 49 or 52mm filter for the appropriate filter thread of the lens, and multiples of them. Really however tho, if stacking was an intent it would have been wiser to start with a cpl that's 52mm or something, then a step up ring, then a ND filter that's 58mm, step up ring and then another ND filter thats stronger perhaps to stack on that at 62mm etc. This way the filters fan out and vignetting becomes less of an issue.
Originally posted by Madaboutpix Appreciated, Bruce. Now we have a voice to attach to your profile image.
Left you a comment on YouTube, too. Somehow I can't bring myself to trust those magnetic things to keep my hard-earned filters securely in place. (Though it would seem that maybe not so much the magnetic ring but the glue keeping it attached to the ring could be a concern.). While I would usually avoid stacking filters, mine could actually be slim enough to get away without vignetting in many circumstances.
Definitely the issue is not magnetic strength (though I wonder if it loses potency over time), the glue issue is definitely the concern. I stacked quite a few together and indeed it feels pretty darn stable. If you were handholding and moving around with them on rather than tripod then I think one magnet filter is all you would be using anyway (a ND filter to get under sync speed or a cpl just). For stacking I think that would mean for most that it's on a tripod and in that regard its magnetically strong.
The slimness of the filters themselves I think can still be an issue. If you use the stacking method like I show then the lens adapter ring that you need to add onto a filter is where the issue lies. For example on one lens (I think HD DA 20-40), I have;
Lens>
Xume Adapter Ring>
Xume Filter holder>CPL>
Xume Adapter Ring> and already vignetting is occurring (at the wider focal lengths) without anything else being stacked yet, because the last Xume Adapter Ring that is needed at the end of the CPL in order for a ND Filter to stack onto that (which then has a Xume Filter Holder as well). If I simply remove the last adapter ring from the CPL then it goes away and is fine (hence why I think this system was developed with no intention to stack. It just depends on focal length, like I say I can get away with quite a bit on the FA77.
What I fail to take into account is the thickness of both a lens adapter AND filter holder that is necessary to go between the two lenses/filters. So it doesn't matter how thin your own filters might be, its the Xume system that will stuff up (hence the idea that you should be forward thinking and plan step up rings into the equation if stacking is what you intend.