Hi Everyone,
Back in 2008 I had used a Giottos MT9360 with a Sigma 500/4.5 + Arca-Swiss Z1 Monoball for the
VLF Wildlife Photo Competition with few issues. Not the best setup, but it certainly worked. No tripod upgrade was really needed until the recent purchase of the
FA* 250-600/5.6 super telephoto. Now I must consider total weight when mounting the following equipment on a tripod:
FA* 250-600/5.6: ~13lbs (with tripod collar)
Wimberley WH-200 gimbal head: 3lbs
Camera + grip + 2 batteries: 2.5lbs
Flash + bracket + extender: 1-2lbs
This means the total weight is hovering around 20lbs! The only exception is to consider using my Arca-Swiss Z1 monoball while shooting in a blind, since no panning ability is really needed. Normally your tripod should have a max. load of double the equipment weight to minimize vibration. I took in a lot of input from fellow nature photographers who use lenses ranging anywhere from 500/4, 600/4, 800/5.6 and Sigma 300-800/5.6 lenses (all Canon/Nikon shooters). That's a big reason why many nature photographers use Gitzo tripods for those heavy super telephoto setups: minimal vibration yet much lighter CF materials. The consensus was the GT3541XLS or GT5541LS.
Just a few days ago I received my Gitzo GT3541XLS along with the GT5541LS. I decided that the 5541LS was a bit too big: a massive top plate/legs, 6.5lbs! For traveling as light as possible, so the 3541XLS is here to stay.
Since I am 6' 3" tall, the following are my requirements that I had for my new tripod purchase:
- max. load capacity of ~40lbs or more
- at least 60" tall without a center column if using a gimbal head
- light weight for travel (~5-6lbs or less)
The gimbal head + lens tripod foot will add at least several inches to this max. height. There are more than a few folks my height using the 5541LS which is sufficient. Since I do a lot of landscape work, an even taller max. height was an important consideration, but I'd rather not buy a center column + plate after the fact. Gitzo is the only manufacturer that I know of that meets all of the above requirements. Many tripods went from 26 to 33lbs max. load, but that's it. That meant no aluminum tripods could be considered (too heavy) and most other competitors' offerings had to be discarded.
I decided to purchase from NatureScapes because they included a free NSN Gitzo safety plate
worth $69.95, a discount of ~$20 for Leg Coat tripod leg covers and free shipping! A nice extra value that came with the tripod. I received a Gitzo box with tripod, tripod dust bag, a small zip lock bag with pamphlet, instructions, warranty card, star hex and standard allen key wrenches & lubricant. Received everything with the accessories listed above in a very well packaged box.
The Gitzo GT3541XLS is a beautiful, simple, strong, yet lightweight CF (Carbon Fiber) tripod with no center column. Here are the specifications:
- Load Capacity: 39.7 lbs (18kg)
- Maximum Height: 78" (198cm)
- Minimum Height: 3.9" (10cm)
- Folded Length: 27.6" (70cm)
- Weight: 4.3 lbs (1.970kg)
The Head Attachment Fitting is 3/8"
Pros:
- Max. load
- Max. height
- Very light weight
- Min. Height
- G locks are fast, simple and strong - simple 1/4 twist to loosen and lock them. Very nice twist locks and grippy rubber covers them!
- Incredibly stiff given the tube diameter - only the 5541LS is stiffer (but much larger).
- Field serviceable and readily available assembly diagrams
- Warranty: 5 additional years with Gitzo if you register with them online.
- Limited Lifetime Warranty if you register online with Bogen Imaging USA. That was a complete surprise - to my knowledge, it's unheard of with any other manufacturer's tripod offerings! If Bogen Imaging cannot repair it, the tripod will be replaced.
Cons:
- Price is not cheap for CF (vs. competitors).
- No padded carry bag - just a thin dust bag.
- Folded length is not as compact as shorter or 3 section tripods, but still quite workable.
- An expensive tripod - putting it in checked luggage should make anyone nervous!
Items received - the NSN Safety Plate, Gitzo GT3541XLS, Leg Coats: The following 2 images are close to actual size: Top plate details:
Length of Gitzo vs. Giottos when folded:
Maximum height:
Safety Plate:
Regarding the NSN Gitzo Safety Plate and it's development:
The combination of a telephoto lens, teleconverter, camera, flash, and tripod head is very heavy. When carrying a tripod over the shoulder, this weight puts additional stress on the tripod plate. After numerous discussions and requests by photographers, we have responded by developing a product that provides additional support to the Gitzo top plate, while offering “peace of mind.” The plate is a perfect fit, positioned snugly below the existing Gitzo plate, inside the “basin.” Once installed, the Gitzo plate can not move or loosen, therefore preventing the head & photo equipment from falling.
Given the value of the equipment I'm slinging over my shoulder while mounted on the tripod, that's a small fee to pay for such a safety plate if you had to buy it. As you can see, those bolts are very stout! You can find a hardware review of the NSN Safety Plate at NatureScapes.
I have always advocated economical tripods such as the Giottos tripod I own (and will continue to do so), but the new weight of the FA* 250-600/5.6 mandated a new support system that met all of my criteria. I'm very pleased with the build quality, fit/finish and lifetime warranty of this tripod. Some folks might disagree with the cost, etc. and there were few choices available!
A very important consideration: the max. height also allows me to stand up while even positioned on a surface with a significant slope or photographing upwards into trees. This means a taller person will not put undue stress on their back: a shorter tripod height or one that allows you to see at eye level on flat ground will force you to stoop to see into the viewfinder on a sloped surface, etc.
Now my last consideration is the hiking/carrying system: probably Kinesis or Lowepro but I haven't really researched all of the options yet. Being airline friendly is always a consideration, so any input/thoughts are welcome!
Regards,
Marc
Last edited by Marc Langille; 11-16-2009 at 05:45 PM.