I've had the katzeye with optibright on my K10D for quite a while, and have recently purchased the Canon Ec-L (cross grid) for my K-7 from Taiwan (focusingscreen.com).
I just did a quick comparison of the two at f4 into a reasonably dark area. The
overall view is clearly brighter with the katzeye. However, the actual "split prism" portion of the two (the little circle doohicky in the middle) is roughly equal in brightness, with the edge possibly going to the Canon Ec-L. Although this is hardly a scientific test (being different cameras and all).
As an aside, I was very happy with the focusingscreen service. I was having a little trouble getting the focus exactly aligned with the provided shims (mostly my own ignorance at the time in all honesty - and yes, shims are provided), but the fellow from focusingscreen sent me out several calibration shims of varying thickness free of charge. I now have my focusing screen perfectly aligned, as tested at macro ranges.