Okay, here is my attempt.
done in lightroom and PS.
1 lowered color temp, exposure and added more contrast
2 cropped the light, I felt it took too much space in the reflection, and cropped the top so reflection and houses matched eachother.
3. exported to PS
4 color ranged the sky, and created a new layer with that, changed layer mode to linear burn and lowered opacity.
5 some selective tweaking of the color range selection,
6. done
7. to come, probably...
I should fix some things that annoy me. But I have a super busy week ahead of me,with 12 to 20 hour workdays from tuesday to sunday.
Edit: I took care of the sky being darker than the reflection. Decided it annoyed the hell out of me and could not leave it even for the time being.