Originally posted by marcusBMG It's common actually for the better tp's of that era to have pretty similar IQ once stopped down.
Competition was very fierce at the time and the photomagazines would print the comparison reviews side-by-side along with bench-measured resolution numbers. As a result, performance was pretty consistent within a market segment.
I hate to say it, but in addition to the Tamron 19AH, I also own the rather nasty, but very compact, Tamron 70-200/4-5.6 158A. I have done table-top testing of these two against each other as well as some limited outdoor stuff and am embarrassed to report that the 158A does much better than expected and essentially equals the 19AH for some subjects.
Steve
(...the 158A is so plasticy I sort of hate to touch it...)