Originally posted by ThorSanchez It's going to be a challenge to tease out the capability of the program from the ability and experience of whomever is using it. You'd almost need 15-20 people who're adept at using each piece of software to eliminate that.
I know that if I was comparing output from LR, Darktable, RawTherapee and Silkypix much of the difference would be my inability to get the most out of the software I'm not as familiar with.
That is why default output is shown. There can be no operator error as I did not touch any sliders or change anything else. The only exception was Luminance HDR, because it requires a decision to be made or it will not render anyhing other than the flat picture profile, which is stated in the text, so there should be no confusion.
And if that conclusion is needed, I would say that Luminance HDR is actually best used for exposure series rather working with a single image of a scene - no surprise there, of course!
I have been thinking if there should be a subsequent part where I use each software for a couple of minutes, state exactly how long I took, and show the outcome. But this first part would still be somewhat more truthful as you could say that some programs perhaps suit me better personally, while another package might work better for someone else, intuitively.