I can't comment on the software you mention. However...
Having been a committed user of Lightroom 6 stand-alone - and occasionally Photoshop Essentials (14, I think - though it may have been 15) for a few years, about a year ago I switched to Darktable and GIMP for raw processing and image editing respectively. After many months of use, I can report with some confidence that they're just as capable as Adobe's commercial products, albeit with some learning curve involved in switching. Both products are open source and, hence, free of any cost unless you should wish to donate. They're actively developed and updated, and there's a great user support network for them. They're available for both Windows and Linux. If you haven't tried them, I'd urge you to do so