Originally posted by feidlera I have about 400 slides that I'd like to scan. I was researching scanners to purchase but am beginning to think the tradeoff between the quality I would get from a $200-$300 scanner may not be as good as what I would get from a scanning service. Other than the time commitment of scanning 400 slides, why would I send them to ScanCafe? Their Pro Option claims 4000 DPI scans and they use a Noritsu scanner (they couldn't give me the model number). Any thoughts on the Pro Option or other scanning service recommendations?
The Noritsu scanner is one of the industry best, but the results will heavily depend on a combination of the quality of the slides and the quality of the person running the scanner. Back in the early 80's I managed a one hour photo lab with the top end Noritsu scanners, printers, processors. Even with state of the art technology, the quality of our work depended on the person operating the technology. A mediocre lab tech with great negs would produce worse results than an excellent lab tech with mediocre negatives.
Unless the lab only has one tech doing all the work, you could send ScanCafe the ProOption service for one excellent and one poor (faded or under exposed, etc) slide as a scanning test. And then after getting it back, send the same two again and you'll get slightly different results. The only way around this is to develop a rapport with the owner/manager and to ask the name of the person doing the scans. If you like "Joe" or "Jane"'s work, then you would request that only that individual do your scans.
This is what the pros do that still shoot film but need high end scans and don't have the patience or time or interest in scanning their own work. But it's a subjective process and often you will pay extra to get results and then ask that it be less green/more magenta, or lighter/darker, etc.
The main reason for scanning film yourself is to have total control. If you still end up with a percentage of bad scans, you'll know it's only because GIGO or the limits of your hardware and software for corrections.
With a $200-300 scanner, you will end up with better scans than a mediocre scanning service, but not as good as a good scanning service. Just keep in mind, their scanner (or yours) is only part of the equation. The human is even more important.
The other complication is that owner/managers have tax incentives to buy better equipment but not to employ more skilled, more expensive labor. And before I became a manager, we were given quotas for the amount of waste or retries we were allowed per week. Wasted time, prints, scans, are a result of operator error, but the realistically if you want quality, there is going to be a certain amount of lost efficiency (or higher labor costs). The Noritsu is a very fast high tech spec scanner, but the results produced for the customer will be dependent on management and your rapport with them.
Ultimately you need to prioritize quality vs. convenience vs. cost to determine whether to scan or to send.