Originally posted by rustynail925 how can you make your photo black and white in lightroom? i've tried using greyscale but it cant really make it a black and white compared to some pictures i've seen.
Marc's right about "seeing" a good B&W. One way, if you have the K20 or K7, is to set up your in-camera view to monotone and then adjust that for in-camera Contrast etc. This lets you evaluate the image for B&W quality in both Preview and on the LCD, and still have the full spectrum RAW data for post processing as color or B&W.
As for the post processing itself, there are dozens of ways to do it, some better than others, some easier than others. You can build your own conversion technique in Photoshop and others, but that's time consuming and may have a steep learning curve for the software. If you just want to get it done without getting that deeply into the process, and if you are using Photoshop, the two best "ready-made" methods I've used are:
PS3, try New Layer>Adjustments>Channel Mixer>Monochrome and adjust the sliders, then try different Layer Modes and Opacity.
PS4, try Adjustments>Black&White play around with the interactive sliders then try different Layer Modes and Opacity.
One interesting technique I'm playing around with now is to layer the adjusted B&W over the color background, mask areas then just lower the opacity a bit to bring out some very subtle colors. Here's an example:
However, my conversion tool of choice is NIK Silver Efex Pro. It costs a bit (does offer a 15-day free trial) but can operate stand alone or as a PS plug-in, and it does everything PS or the other software does, but does it easier and faster and with better control. Its two advantages are combining localized spot control with extensive film-types.
Good luck,
Brian