Originally posted by Navmaxlp If you're a good photographer, you're a good photographer.
I would counter: If you're a good photographer, you practiced your art and studied your craft intensely.
Originally posted by Navmaxlp However, I do think it's easier to get a better picture with a digital camera when learning to shoot.
You can more easily get a "quality image", but digital doesn't make photographs better.
Originally posted by Navmaxlp With digital cameras, you have instant feed back when taking a picture. If you miss the composition or something was wrong in your set up, you can go back immediately and fix it.
"Fixing it" doesn't make you better at the craft. Learning to get it right the first time makes you better. Delayed feedback motivates one to do the latter more expeditiously.
Originally posted by Navmaxlp In the film days, you had to get it shoot and find out later how it turned out. Kinda had to get it right the first time out.
And there's the money. We learned to get it right the first time.
Originally posted by Navmaxlp I remember taking a multiple exposure pic of a friend of mine. Was trying to get him centered in a shot then multiple exposure a picture of some stuff he had written in a book. Took me several trial and errors to get it lined up correctly. Also, it's easier to play around and experiment in PP with digital. A lot more leg work in the dark room. It was a LOT of fun in there but, it took more time and effort.
Ease and convenience do not equal mastery of craft.
I don't mean to pick on you, or single you out. What you are stating here is a just a pretty good summation of the "digital is better" argument. The argument that easier is better just falls flat with me.
Skill in photography most certainly is the product of the effort put into it (genetic aptitude surely helps). But I, and some others, would argue that "hardship" is a powerful teaching tool.
The military makes boot camp extremely difficult for a reason. They want the best trained soldiers they can get and they know that if they make the recruits struggle for success they will emerge far better educated and prepared for their duties. And no, I am not implying that shooting film is anything nearly as intense as boot camp; I've been through both and know full well the difference. But, what does not kill us makes us stronger.