Originally posted by edgedemon They are both good, I personally like the 1st better, I think the dirt in the bottom right adds something, but that is purely my opinion.
Personal taste for sure. But make a test. Move the slider on you monitor down to put the cropped version on screen and look at it. O.K. wait a moment and now move up and look at the original. You will notice that your eyes dont focus immediately on the ant but on the piece of timber, yet the ant is or ought to be the centre of attention, namely the very reason for the close up macro shot in the first place. I believe a frame filling macro shot is just that a frame filling shot where the object is magnified for closer inspection.
So in my book the cropped version appeals to me more. That's my take of it, but thankfully we are all different.
Greetings