Originally posted by MossyRocks I've done a similar edit to a different sunset and while it does seem to be getting into the over cooked category sometimes that works. It seems the general popolus likes things like sunsets on the over done side just like the overdone HDR. It had crossed my mind to do it that way.
Looking at it again, I think this really think a Lightroom graduated filter or two would work wonders a the sky and water could use different amounts of saturation and luminosity. One from the top down and one from the bottom up A great photo with tons of scope for PP.
Cheers