Originally posted by Martin Stu interesting place
Thank you for your kind comment.
---------- Post added 28-11-21 at 10:34 PM ----------
Originally posted by WileyB Tough! Both are really nice, vibrant greens and lovely setting.
I like the glow of the background much better in the second picture and I think it adds much to the image.
But, I like the form of the beech subject better in the first. Flows more and draws the eye along its path better. And the plants at the base really seem to pop and dance!
Thank you for the thoughtful comment, much appreciated. I agree with you concerning the best characteristics of the two photos. And I like si much the conclusion of your comment, where you noticed that the plants at the base of the tree 'pop and dance'! Warm regards, Maurizio
---------- Post added 28-11-21 at 10:42 PM ----------
Originally posted by angkymac Both are the kind of shots I really like.
And if the background seems too busy to suit a particular discipline of photography, well--so what?
The image conveys the message of the beech tree as a member of that forest community.
Angky.
Dear Angky, thank you for your kind comment. You are right, we should not be too much formulaic (I hope this word is appropriate, my English is limited), I feel we should mainly judge a photo by its capability to convey a message. Warm regards, Maurizio
---------- Post added 28-11-21 at 10:46 PM ----------
Originally posted by PJ1 I like both shots. I don't think the backgrounds are too busy. It shows the environment.
Thank you for the kind and encouraging comment! Best regards, Maurizio
---------- Post added 28-11-21 at 11:00 PM ----------
Originally posted by Ausable The backgrounds in both images are pretty busy. However, the main subject captures the eye initially. The background in the 2nd image is uniform in type and texture, so it seems less of a distraction than the background in the 1st image. I do like the subject and both images are very nice.
Thank you for the thougthful comment and for the evaluation of the two shots! Warm regards, Maurizio
---------- Post added 28-11-21 at 11:04 PM ----------
Originally posted by shyrsio I can smell this picture. Very nice!
This is a truly interesting and complimentary comment! Thank you! Warm regards, Maurizio
---------- Post added 28-11-21 at 11:12 PM ----------
Originally posted by victordeamorin Very nice shots, I do prefer the second one. Have you tried a square crop to remove the right part of the picture (branch laying on the ground, mossy Hill)? That could simplify it and re-center it o' your main subject
Thank you for your useful and kind comment. I will try to crop the right part of tge picture, this could be a good suggestion (yes, that little branch is a but disturbing). :-) Warm regards, Maurizio