Last night I found myself watching a nice YouTube Leica presentation on the new APO M Summicron 35mm f2 ASPH lens. Very nice looking lens, promises a lot, I wondered how much it is in NZ?
A little back story. 9 years ago I was shooting a Nikon D200 and wanted something smaller, lighter, more modern, and preferably weather sealed for landscapes and travel. The main comparison came down to the Nikon D7000 verses the Pentax K5. The Pentax came out ahead in my evaluation at the time, so I swapped systems, and have stayed with Pentax since. I also seriously looked at Leica at the time 9 years ago, but whilst small and portable was very expensive and not weather sealed.
I really like Leica's lenses, and have Leitaxed a Leica R 90mm f2.8, and might do the same for some other Leica lenses in the future, as I enjoy using old manual focus lenses - which was also another attraction of entering the Pentax system 9 years ago.
So back to last nights small bit of camera purchasing analysis. I wondered to myself what a full frame camera, film camera, and three prime lens kit might be in NZ for both Leica and Pentax. I currently have digital and film cameras that share lenses, so this was the idea behind the kit specification
Leica: M10R (40MP), MP (film camera), APO Sumicron f2 M lenses - 35mm, 50mm and 90mm. This is the classic Leica 3 lens set. The APO Sumicron M lenses are top specification and very expensive, nothing but the best for this comparison. All equipment new prices listed in $NZ including GST at list prices. Note none of the Leica kit is particularly water resistant
Pentax: K-1 II, K-3 III (assumed $3K price), LX (2nd hand for film camera), FA 31/1.8, DFA 50/1.4, DFA 85 1.4. All priced NZ new except the LX film camera. I am not sure how the DFA lenses would work on the LX, but I wanted to spec in the newest and best quality primes for the comparison. In my opinion the FA31 is the pick of the available new Pentax primes around the 35mm focal range. I added both the FF and APS-C cameras, because I could afford to in this comparison, and it seemed a nice idea. You can do the math of taking the K-3 III out of the comparison if you want to. $NZ including GST at list prices.
This comparison was of the manufacturers lenses, and excluded third party lenses - which are available for both Pentax K, and Leica M systems. I also wanted best quality available lens kits and full frame cameras from the manufacturer.
Other notes: this is of course comparing a rangefinder system with a DSLR system, and perhaps a better true comparison would have been Pentax K system verses Leica SL system. The analysis started with looking at a video of the new M system APO Leica 35/2 so that is why the comparison was done that way. The Leica kit is a lot smaller and more portable.
So the comparison dollars for the two kits above:
Leica Kit: M10R, MP, APO Summicron f2 35mm, 50mm and 90mm NZ$58,570
Pentax Kit: K-1 II, K-3 III (assumed $3K), LX, FA31mm, DFA 50mm, DFA 85mm NZ$13,900
The price of the APO Summicron f2 35mm that started this analysis $12,900 - that is right, you can buy the entire Pentax kit for $1,000 more than one nice new Leica lens.
From time to time here on Pentax Forum I see people grizzling about how expensive Pentax is, and because of that they are leaving yada yada yada.
From this analysis, Pentax is incredibly affordable - yes I am comparing it with a luxury product, and yes those Leica lenses have the mythical Leica 'look' and bokeh to die for, but is it worth four times the cost? Some of course say yes, for me I remain very happy with the value proposition that Pentax offers us.
Analysis complete
Cheers
Ross