Hey everyone!
I'm finally up and running again at the new place. Just in time to be halfway through my stint in Southern AZ already! Anyways, I've gotten around to processing and printing a backlog of film. Recently, I picked up a nice 645 MF, and if what I'm seeing is true, I may get a nice speed grip, a nice metering prism, and be done with 35mm...
So, I shoot FP4 in both formats. Recently I was printing 5x7's from FP4 in 135 and 120 (developed together, shot at the same time). From everything I've heard/read about things, there should be no visible difference between the formats when printed at 5x7.
Unfortunately, I can't really upload scans, so I'll try to describe as best as I can:
I printed a shot of an old rusty Thunderbird at sunset from a 645 negative with lots of small foreground detail in leaves and rocks on the ground (75mm f/5.6 at 1/60). I also printed a similar 35mm shot (Super Tak 35mm f/3.5 f/6.8, 1/125).
The Super Tak 35mm f/3.5 is my sharpest 35mm lens, and my 75mm EII is pretty good as well. Looking closely at the prints, the 35mm print looks a bit sharper overall, but I can attribute that to the massive mirror in my ETRS and shooting handheld. However, if I put my reading glasses on and look closely, the MF print has more..... micro contrast and micro detail, plus the tonality looks a bit smoother. The leaves, rocks, and bark in the 35mm shot look good, but it just doesn't have the same level of tiny details that the MF print has... It almost looks over-sharpened in comparison.
Both were done on a Componon 75mm EL lens @ f/11. D76 1:3 for the developing of film.
Anyways, with everything I have read, I shouldn't be seeing this much of a difference at this level. Is D76 1:3 too dilluted/sharp for 35mm film, giving it an 'oversharpened' look?
Has anyone else had these had these same revelations with Medium Format and 35mm? Am I destined to never want to make an 8x10 from 35mm again?
I'll try to upload small crops of the prints to demonstrate. It's kind of like comparing the butteriness of creamy vs crunchy peanut butter...
If there's this much difference to my eye at this level, I guess I'll be super happy when my new Burke & James 4x5 gets here next week...... The one I accidentally bought for $20.49