having heard the over processed thing a bit recently
FIrst , peter Lik has sold a photo for 1 million dollars...
https://www.pentaxforums.com/forums/38-photographic-technique/203024-who-took...hotograph.html
Second...
-The contrast in life is 20,000 to one on occasion
-Your computer monitor might be 500 to one realistically
-A print might be 120 to one, in newspaper of magazine, at most 60:1
There is absolutely nothing I can do in post to match the brilliance of the original scene.
So the rule for photographers in high contrast / situations has always been, bump until you start to lose image detail, then tone it down a wee bit, make sure you get all your detail back..
So, my comment on the over-processed thing is... did he lose detail?
The corollary would be, if you don't know that, you're really not is a position to comment.
Occasionally I have a scene provided by mother nature that is so brilliant barely process at all. And I get too I've over -processed.
-Well there are two possibilities when this comment is made. 1, I've over-processed and the commenter right.
- or... 2. I've captured a really brilliant scene with spectacular light, and I have to admit, I rarely take an image that doesn't fall into that category.. and the commenter just doesn't understand the dynamics o the process.
I'm sure there are other ways of thinking about this issue. Everyone has an opinion... but this is a good one. Taught in major photography departments around the world.
But's it's always hilarious when someone thinks my images don't represent what I see. Like they were standing beside me and saw the same scene when I took the picture. They have no idea what I was looking at.
Most of the time the scene is way more contrasty, way more saturated and way sharper than anything I could do with a camera.
I do have some low contrast images, taken in fog etc, some of my favourites which are essentially low contrast monotones.. I'm not saying every image has to be saturated over the top. I am saying my photography has always been at the high end of the contrast scale compared to some of my teaching colleagues... and I definitely seek out high contrast photo ops, whether it be colour contrast or tonal contrast... so shoot me.
Peter Lik's million dollar image.
One of mine... compared to what Peter Lik sells his for, mine are cheap....
OK so his is better, just saying...