Originally posted by gavincato It just didn't have that magic look to me like some of the older lenses do. My opinion only, I'm sure others would disagree!
Hmm. That's a lot of magic to give up AF, SR and macro capabilities over, but of course the other lens is of a wider aperture and is longer, so I'm sure there's something to it's look.
In any case, there are only two aspects that matter to me in terms of "look", how well a lens performs wide open and whether the bokeh is totally round and buttery smooth. Doesn't matter what the actual aperture and focal length is otherwise.