Originally posted by rdenney Most lenses have a special purpose, and I eventually run into most special purposes for which a given lens will be optimal. I don't understand selling off special-purpose lenses in order to simplify--my life is simplified when I have exactly the correct lens for a situation. It's sorta like the old story of the young wedding photographer who told his mentor, "I prefer to shoot with available light" and the mentor responded, "if you had a flash in the trunk of your car, it would be available."
I do understand not taking the whole kit when the purpose is known beforehand, or when transport space is limited, such as when traveling by air.
My beef with that Peak pack (and I spent some time with one at the store) is the side entry. I can see dumping stuff on the ground, or having to climb through some stuff to get other stuff--in my view the principle sins of any camera case.
"One Bag to Rule Them All" has never worked for me. I have a bunch of bags, and find each is optimal for a different situation than the others. Sometimes, a bag can be my primary carry-on (for US domestic flights: 14x22x9 inches), and I have a LowePro Photo Trekker Classic that holds a 67 plus about 8 lenses, or an old Outpack that holds a Canon kit including about a dozen lenses. Sometimes, it's the personal item (9x10x17", though I've never seen it enforce if the bag was obviously smaller than a full-sized carry-on), such as the ThinkTank Streetwalker Pro that I use for the 645z. Sometimes, it has to sling over a should and weight no more than 7Kg (as on a flight from New Zealand to Australia), and for that I have an ultralight Tampac over-the-shoulder bag. Sometimes, I want to use the bag around my neck as a chest back for one camera, and I have an SLR bag with a lens pound attached to one side that holds my Canon with a 24-105 zoom, and a 70-200 on the side, plus a flash. That's a quick "just gotta bring a camera to make a few pictures" bag, and I think the Crumpler bag fits that description pretty well, if the central pocket is big enough for the 67 (and the pictures fill me with doubt on that one).
Soft bags do not protect equipment all that well. In the music world, we call them "dent bags". I have some hard cases for when I will need to stack a lot of equipment on a cart. Some of them have wheels, too.
So, for me, bags are like tripods--I have ended up with a collection of them, because each fulfills a unique set of requirements related to specific use cases, and no one bag address all my use cases.
Rick "who even has a shoulder bag for a Speed Graphic plus extra lens and six film holders" Denney
Rick, thanks for the insight. I haven't sold any lenses that I enjoy using. Most of what I have sold or intend to sell is stuff that came as a package. Seller wouldn't part it out, so it all ended up at my front door. I'm just as happy to give some of that stuff away or let my daughter use it and not lose any sleep or worry about a damaged lens.
We obviously have different needs for bags. I don't have 12 different focal length lenses for 35mm that'd I'd want to take all at the same time. I only have four lenses for my 645n kit and two for the 6x7. I also can't see when or why I'd want to take all of that stuff together on the same trip. I'm starting to lean towards the 6x7 and two lenses I have and a 35mm and digital P&S cameras for the snapshots and nights/evenings. For a lot people, on vacation (not photo work), I'm willing to bet simplicity is a camera and as few lenses as possible to be focused on relaxing and enjoying the time on vacation without fretting about which lens or camera combo to use. Just enjoy being there.
My 38L Deuter bag has worked as a carry on, and fit in the overhead bins, for domestic and international flights. Saw an earlier post about boarding early to ensure you get the space and I'm usually on the plane pretty early. I don't do a ton of air travel right now, but as my children get a bit older and capable of more adventurous travel and destinations, I'm sure that will pick up. I understand the idea of the right tool for the job, but I think most people could make things work with a "close enough" equivalent with a camera lens. Probably not necessary to have 10 lenses with some duplicate copies between 24-55mm.
As far as the Crumpler 7, another member emailed me pictures of a 6x7 kit with two lenses in the Crumpler 6 and the 7 is bigger.