Originally posted by rdenney The 180mm Zeiss Jena Sonnar is a lens for portraits. The bokeh is creamy—perhaps the best of any medium format short telephoto lens ever made for faded edge bokeh.
I work with the Leica APO-Elmar 180mm f/3.5 CS lens which like the CZJ 180mm, is absolutely superb for portraiture on the Leica S. I'm just saying it - Leica could make a
killing if they decided to make those lenses for other camera mounts.
Originally posted by rdenney he Pentax lenses will have more contrast at low spatial frequencies, a reflection of Pentax’s design sensibilities.
I think this has more to do with the quality and number of optical coatings than any inherent optical design philosophy. The later PS series lenses from Bronica held a distinct advantage* in image contrast compared to the older S line, merely by improving the coatings.
Originally posted by rdenney The CZJ 120 is not a Sonnar, but a Biometar, similar to a 5-element Planar.
Biometar/Biotar** is east German parlance for Planar. "..A rose by any other name..."
The name Biometar/Biotar/Planar pre-date WW2. Naming conventions were adhered to more strictly than they are now.
* what made this more obvious is a lot of the optical formulas used in the S and PS line were identical.
** Biotar is an Assymetrical Planar, a Biometar is a tweak of the planar formula, which is comprised of 5 elements. Where the Biometar diverges from the Planar design only by substituting the rear doublet by high curvature singlet elements.