Originally posted by shadowbecomeswhite Hello All,
1) I know few artists take photos with just a pinhole camera with 4x5 Ilford film and then scan to get beautiful results. How does that compare to a Pentax or a Mamiya 645 digital medium format camera ? Sure the lens, helps you focus but are there any other advantages ?
You'll find that a 645 is in most ways just like any other 35mm SLR, just a little bigger and heavier. Of course, you load the film differently, but in most other respects they are the same. The 67 is heavier still, sometimes too heavy to handhold. A 4x5 pinhole camera sounds like fun for some applications but just doesn't have the versatility of a SLR system.
Quote: I read that the Mamiya DL28 creates RAW files of size = 53MB. My K10D creates RAW=16MB. So ok, higher dynamic range ... but can I get close to the same quality if I use film and a top scanner ?
Bigger RAW doesn't necessarily mean more DR, especially when the sensors are so different.
As for a "top scanner" I am going to assume you mean a top consumer scanner, because high-end Imacon and drum scanners cost a small fortune.
I have a Epson V700, for which I paid $475 at Adorama. I chose the V700 because the Nikon Coolscan 9000 is our of my price range and I can eventually get a wet-mounting kit from ScanScience for it. (The Epson V750 has it's own wet-mount kit but from all I have read the ScanScience kit is better.)
Quote: 2) I'd like to experiment with medium format photography but can't afford a digital medium format. I don't mind learning how to develop film. So which film based medium format camera would you recommend and which scanner would be a must to get best results ?
At the risk of sounding like a Pentax fangirl, for film only, get a Pentax 645N or 645NII system. They are far less expensive than Mamiya 645AF or Contax 645AF systems, and Contax stuff can be a bit harder to come by.
If autofocus isn't important to you, than you have a great many more choices. If you think you'd like to upgrade to a digital back in the future, the Mamiya 645AFD would by my choice.
I have my film developed at a pro lab, it costs me $8 a roll for 120 color E-6 and $7.25 for 120 B&W film, uncut & sleeved. C-41 is a bit cheaper. The lab does 4x5 film for $3 each.
Buffy