Originally posted by ivanvernon Amsterdam and Rotterdam last time I was there were filthy--all kinds of crap in canals in Amsterdam, dirty paper and trash blowing everywhere in the streets. The two places in Europe that I found to be clean were Switzerland and Germany.
I have found fairly clean places in cities all over the world, and also fairly trashy places. It is not simply a matter of someone from France's perception of municipal make-work programs in the USA. It's far more a matter of economic conditions in that neighborhood.
Switzerland is indeed clean. But many buildings in Switzerland are not at all clean, and are marked up with graffiti, in places tourists don't usually go. So, the Rue-du-Rhone in Geneva is spotless, but the old Zodiac building in Le Locle, not so much.
You will not see a lot of trash blowing in the streets in many places in the US. But we don't depend on municipal workers in those places. We simply pick up after ourselves, and each keep our own property clean. That is not a universal truth anywhere. I travel to New York frequently, and parts of even Manhattan are quite clean. Parts are not.
I've never been one to photograph poor neighborhoods, for several reasons. 1. I don't live there and being there is a presumption that is poorly seen by the residents. They don't feel it is the job of the financially secure to represent their plight, and they generally do not enjoy being portrayed as living in squalor. There are ways to approach people authentically, but I'm willing to confess that I lack that skill. 2. There are photographers in those areas who have skill and vision, and they know what to see while I don't. 3. That's not the sort of thing that interests me in photography in the first place.
Streetscapes with buildings can be interesting to me, but like the photo we are discussing, I prefer them without people, and certainly without recognizable people. That's difficult in vibrant city areas, of course. But I live in a rural area and that's more my milieu.
Rick "much of what made cities dirty was burning coal, now much more rare" Denney