Originally posted by tibbitts
This is somewhat off-topic, but it seems like you learning film today would be like forcing computer science majors to learn to read punched cards by holding them up to the light (something we had to do in my first computer class, a long time ago.)
Paul
Ok, so this thread is old, and I'm still pretty new to thoughtful photography, but I saw this comment and thought I'd offer my observation:
This is the fourth Major Subject I've been involved in where old-school vs new'school has been a hot topic. In the Navy, I was involved with an area of electronic study where some guys were trained to work on one very large system, using modern techniques, which pretty much involved following a flow-chart and doing what the voices told you. Other guys, like me, went through a course where several smaller systems were taught together, and because the theory was so varied, one system to another, what we were taught was analog electronics, which we would apply to whatever situation came to us. Every time the guys on my boat got stuck after 30 minutes of flow-chart troubleshooting, they'd just give up and come get me, and I'd approach their problem like a technician, not a librarian.
I then went into computers, learning odd systems first, then DOS, then Linux and Windows. Younger guys ask me how I can know certain stuff without having ever seen it before - it's not because I'm smarter, but because I know the heritage of Windows. The current system evolved from something that wasn't so complicated it took a rocket scientist to figure out, and so I'm able to extrapolate new information from what I do know.
Lastly, I work in an industry where the present systems are pretty, glossy, and PC-based. But I know the background of how each parameter, setting, and feature evolved. Turns out several competing systems in the field are essentially cut from the same cloth - and thus easy to figure out - to the person with the right experience.
In light of all this, while I don't know if it will work retro-actively, I'm going to teach myself to shoot film. My K20d died the other day, and so out of necessity, I"m pressing the Spotmatic I bought for nothing more than the 50/1.4 lens it came with into service. I've shot film before, long time ago, so it's not totally new. I can already attest to a better understanding of my digital shooting. More power to the original poster. Good for him, hope he learned lots!