Weight vs. Stability vs. Compactness vs. Stability vs. Utility vs. Stability vs. Price vs. Stability vs. Build vs. Stability vs. Capacity
ummmm...I seem to have put stability in there more than once. Go figure.
All of the above factors are in a state of dynamic tension. Emphasize one and you get a shift on the others. I am firmly convinced that there is no magic point of convergence even if price is allowed to float freely.
I finally ended up with a mix based on function:
- Giottos MT9360 for the K10D (general use) and Chamonix field camera.
- Giottos 1301 ballhead for the K10D (or the 645N I have been jonesing on for the last year or so)
- Bogen 3028 3-D head for the Chamonix on the 9360. What is amazing is that it weighs no more than the ballhead. Also in its favor is that it will support any of my cameras, though at the price of flexibility and bulk. It also looks rather queer to have the tiny FED-2 or XA mounted!
- Slik 330-DX for the backpack. It can handle anything in my quiver except for the Chamonix (various 35mm film cameras and the K10D), though it is not nearly as stable or as versatile as the Giottos.
- Manfrotto 494 ballhead for the Slik. The combination weighs in at about 3#. For a full discussion of this setup see my posts on Hin's blog HERE and HERE
- Cheap Giottos monopod (bundled free with the 9360) for when I need to be light/compact and even the Slik is too much.
For what its worth, the 9360 has hit the trail on occasion. The Chamonix is, after all, a field camera and a field camera must have its support.
My advice? Start off in a camera store that caters to pros and which has a decent selection (say three competing lines). Find which models seem to meet your needs and don't be afraid to come to the store with gear bag in hand to see how the support handles the load. Take notes (in writing) regarding likes/dislikes. Do not consider price at this point.
Once you have a good idea what fits your needs, go home with your notes and scour the web to find the competition for your top choice. Use the Web to make your short list of candidates. If at all possible, check out your top choice in person before making the purchase. I learned the hard way with the purchase of a laughably flimsy tripod at the same price point as the 330-DX at the price of shipping both ways. (The QR plate was about the size of my thumbnail!)
If at all possible, buy local at the brick and mortar store. Online prices for tripods are not that competitive for quality tripods and it is good to support the merchants who maintain the stock on the shelves.
Steve
BTW...exotic materials may save weight, but usually at the price of capacity, stability, and $$$...and yes, even Gitzo can and will fail in the field...great warranty though!