Originally posted by Anvh Not too fast, just the pupil is not correct, we are talking about the entrance pupil. I'm not sure but with retro focus is then the exit pupil used?
you are misreading my comment. I explicitly stated that
above 50mm (i.e. non retro focus lenses) the entrance pupil works fine.
I agree it may not apply in retrofocus lenses, but, when dealing with telephotos, in all 30 years of photography, I have NEVER seen a telephoto that had a bigger front element than was dictated by what was needed to get the specified maximum aperture..
note that there is simply no need to have a retrofocusing lens when the focal length is above the system regestry distance, and why would you place extra elements, all of which have transmission losses and contrast reducing flare (regardless of how good the coatings are) when you don't need it.