Originally posted by HSV A newbie question...and I don't have an OS lens, it's just curiosity. Is it possible to use both OS and SR at the time? What would happen? Is it actually beneficial or it is a detriment to have them both on?
In answer to your question, yes you can. Do you want to? No!
If the lens is compensating for shake, it will be moving the image that is projected on the sensor to compensate for shake. If the sensor is also moving so compensate shake you can see the lens, which assumes the sensor is in a fixed place is not going to work so well once the sensor is moving. And the sensor will be trying to compensate for the apparent movement of the image which is caused by the lens. Basically it will be creating shake where it is not actually even there.
If Pentax and sigma were to design the system to work together there is a possibility of accommodating heavier shake. But this probably will never happen.