The other reason might because they are old batch, lack of use for long time. That's why I'd rather buy later version of these FA lenses, even the AIV ones
I've had MIJ and AIV versions, some how those AIV versions work smoother and seem sharper wide open. Ended up I sold all my MIJ version, now only keeping an AIV FA31.
As to black vs silver, I prefer silver one here because the black FA lenses don't have the same quality surface coating/finishing as the silver ones. Black ones got scratched easily, especially the 31 and 43.